Is It Worth Keeping a Rental Property?

Serena Irving • January 13, 2019

Is It Worth Keeping a Rental Property?

By Serena Irving

Residential property investors were targeted in the latest tax Bill before Parliament in December 2018. The Bill is likely to have the numbers to pass into Law, so if you have rental property or are considering investing, keep reading.

Figure 1 : Photo by Alex D'Alessio on Unsplash

The proposal to "ring-fence tax losses" means that investors who previously offset rental losses against other earnings will no longer be able to do so. Rental losses of one property can be offset against other rental profits in the person's portfolio, or against gains from the sale of properties, or carried forward to offset future rental profits/gains.

The change will take effect from the start of the 2020 income year (1 April 2019 for most taxpayers). If you are considering any major repairs, we suggest that you complete them before 31 March 2019. The rule changes do not affect a person's main home or mixed-used properties such as beach houses, but do apply to overseas residential rental properties.

Under the bright-line property rules from 29 March 2018, people who sell a house in New Zealand within five years of buying it must pay income tax on any gains, unless it's their main home or another exception applies.

In addition, there are increased requirements on landlords for giving notice, limiting rent increases and improving living standards. It may be tempting for some landlords to consider selling their investment properties, even though there is a rental property shortage.

Without the tax refund, would you have enough funds available to cover vacancies or major maintenance work? Auckland Property Investors Association board member Amanda Watts said in her June 2018 blog, Removal of Negative Gearing, "My concern is that for some landlords this may mean the difference between doing or not doing maintenance if there is no immediate tax relief. They might have to postpone the repairs until another year, increasing the risk that the property will deteriorate and that vacancies might result." Source: www.apia.org.nz/apia-blog

There are a lot of factors to consider other than the tax. What are your long-term investment objectives? Could you get a better return in other investments? Could you pay down the mortgage to reduce interest costs? Could you increase rents to improve your income?

If you would like to chat about how the ring-fencing of tax losses will affect you, please give us a call.

Download a PDF version here or contact the author by email . Like our Facebook page for regular tips.

Serena Irving is a director in JDW Chartered Accountants Limited, Ellerslie, Auckland. JDW is a professional team of qualified accountants, auditors, business consultants, tax advisors, trust and business valuation specialists.

By Serena Irving July 30, 2026
Imagine if supplier bills landed in your accounting system automatically, with fewer errors and less manual data entry. What if your customers could process your invoices faster too? eInvoicing can help small businesses save time, reduce administration, and improve cashflow by sending invoice data directly between accounting systems.
By Serena Irving July 28, 2026
One of the first decisions you'll make when starting a business is choosing the right business structure. The option you choose affects how much tax you pay, how much paperwork you'll have, and how much personal risk you take if things go wrong. While many businesses start as sole traders, that's not always the best choice. As your business grows it’s often possible to change to a more suitable structure. Here's a simple guide to help you understand your options. 
By Serena Irving June 3, 2026
Budget 2026 includes proposed changes to New Zealand’s foreign investment fund (FIF) rules. These are the tax rules that can apply when New Zealand residents invest in overseas shares. The changes will be relevant to direct investors in foreign companies, as well as founders, early investors and others affected by offshore migration or foreign listing events. Below is a summary of the key proposals announced on 28 May 2026. As these measures are still proposed, the final details may change as the legislation progresses.
By Serena Irving May 29, 2026
It may have started as a hobby, or a one-off sale of goods, but at some point, you realise that you have a business. If you are making losses, you may be able to deduct the losses from your other taxable income. If you are making profits, you may need to pay tax.
More Posts